Nov 20, 2026, 8:30 a.m. EST
4 min read
Summary
- Automated attackers targeted deliberately vulnerable Bitcoin wallets within seconds after Belgian researchers exposed a signing error that can reveal private keys.
- A review of six blockchains through June 2024 recovered 3,620 private keys, including 3,278 on Bitcoin, by identifying reused signature numbers known as nonces.
- Vulnerable addresses’ peak balances totaled about $106 million at November 2024 prices, but the researchers did not establish how much money was actually stolen.
Somewhere on the Bitcoin network, automated programs are believed to lie in wait for wallet software to make a very old mistake that helps them siphon off funds. And when two Belgian researchers made that mistake on purpose, the bots showed up within seconds.
Vincent Jacquot and Benoît Donnet, computer scientists at the University of Liège, put $3 to $5 each into Bitcoin and Ethereum accounts that they had deliberately left vulnerable, then watched to see what would happen.
On Bitcoin, the attacks began “a second or a few seconds after the bait was set up,” Jacquot shared with CoinDesk this week. At least two rival transactions raced to claim the coins while they sat in the mempool, a kind of waiting room where transactions sit before the network confirms them.
The experiment highlights a broader vulnerability in Bitcoin’s open, permissionless design. Once a transaction enters the mempool, it is visible to everyone. That allows automated attackers to monitor the network around the clock, waiting for predictable mistakes rather than targeting individual victims.
It also shows why wallet security cannot rely on users alone. Developers, wallet providers, and exchanges need to build safeguards that prevent common errors from becoming instantly exploitable opportunities for bots.
A CoinDesk analysis of one of the traps shows how it played out.
The flaw involves the way Bitcoin wallets sign payments. Every signature relies on a random number, called a nonce, that is supposed to be used only once. If the same secret key ever signs two transactions with the same nonce, anyone who sees both can work out the key with a little algebra and take the money.
It is like using the same one-time password for two different bank transactions. Once someone sees both, they may be able to work out the underlying password and take control of the account.
The researchers sent 7,200 satoshis, the smallest unit of bitcoin, worth a few dollars, to each of six newly created addresses from one wallet. About an hour later, two of those addresses paid each other, both using the same nonce. That alone gave nothing away, because -two different keys had signed the transactions.
Then, one of the pair signed a third payment with that nonce – meaning a single key had reused its nonce – and the math to unlock it was there for anyone to do.
The next transaction out of that address sent its remaining 5,200 satoshis, worth a few dollars, to a stranger. It was signed with the bait’s own private key and landed in a block nine minutes later. The 4,700 satoshis that reached the thief’s address have not moved since.
How bots wait for Bitcoin wallets that reuse nonces. (Shaurya Malwa/CoinDesk)
Its partner address was exposed too, because once one key falls, the shared nonce gives up the other. That address sat untouched for 13 days, until another sweep months later.
That mistake is what the researchers went looking for across the wider crypto market.
Under the most common signing method, known as ECDSA, wallet software produces that signature by combining two ingredients. One is the owner’s private key, the secret that controls the coins. The other is a fresh random number meant to be used only once.
Jacquot and Donnet, who work at the university’s Montefiore Institute, scanned every ECDSA signature on six blockchains, from each network’s launch through June 30, 2024, searching for that mistake.
They recovered 3,620 private keys. The vast majority – 3,278 – came from the Bitcoin blockchain. Dogecoin accounted for 195, Ethereum for 119, Litecoin for nine, Bitcoin Cash for six and Dash for one.
Fifteen of the keys turned up only when the researchers searched all six networks at once. That meant some faulty wallet software had reused nonces across different blockchains. At their peak, the addresses tied to those 15 keys held just under $2,100.
$106 million in historical exposure
The researchers took each vulnerable address’s highest balance and valued it at cryptocurrency prices from Nov. 25, 2024. Those separate peaks added up to €101 million, about $106 million, Jacquot told CoinDesk.
The calculation assumes an attacker reached every address at its richest moment and that victims never topped up afterward. The team did not establish how much was actually stolen.
Most of the exposure dates to bitcoin’s early years. The vulnerable pot topped $1 million nine times, mostly between 2014 and early 2016, and peaked near $26 million in December 2014.
Later spikes of about $12 million in 2022 and roughly $1 million in 2023 came mostly from Ethereum.
Withdrawals that look like attacks go back years. The earliest bitcoin activity the paper flags as possible attacks dates to the fourth quarter of 2015.
On Ethereum, deposits of 6 ETH and then 350 ETH into one exposed address in November 2022 were claimed by another address 12 seconds after they landed. “Our paper doesn’t try to differentiate real attacks from benign withdrawals,” Jacquot said.
Attackers appear to skip some chains. The authors found that Dogecoin, Dash and Litecoin “are likely not under active scrutiny by attackers.”
“Most of the currently vulnerable funds” sit at a single bitcoin address that uses an uncommon format, according to the paper, which does not publish the address or a current balance.
Weak randomness keeps costing bitcoin holders money. In July, a flaw in how Coldcard hardware wallets generated private keys let attackers drain 594 BTC in a first 25-minute sweep.
Originally published at https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2026/11/20/bitcoin-bots-pounced-within-seconds-when-researchers-exposed-their-keys.