Federal Reserve policymakers are advocating for additional interest rate increases relying on inflation figures that experts argue are outdated, highlighting a sharp recent decline in gasoline, oil, and most other commodities as proof that inflationary pressures are subsiding.
This appears to be a classic instance of central banks lagging behind developments, as they depend on historical metrics such as the consumer price index (CPI) and the producer price index (PPI), which measure what consumers and manufacturers paid during the previous month.
Real-time pricing metrics like crack spreads, gasoline futures, and retail pump prices instead indicate that inflationary strains are decreasing.
“Inflation is a lagging indicator. It tells you what you paid last month. The crack spread is a leading indicator. It tells you what you’ll pay next month. One says inflation is too high. The other says it’s already falling. The Fed is listening to the first one. It’s about to hike into falling prices at the pump,” said Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Arvy, a Zurich-based asset management firm regulated by Swiss financial watchdog FINMA.
These apprehensions regarding rate hikes, which create headwinds for bitcoin, are supported by the release of the Federal Reserve’s October meeting minutes along with recent statements from central bank representatives.
The minutes published Wednesday indicated that “in the months ahead, almost all participants judged that, under their baseline outlooks for inflation and the labor market, further action to raise the target range for the federal funds rate” would likely be appropriate “in order to ensure a timely return of inflation to the 2% objective.”
Two officials went even further, advocating for an increase of “more than 25 basis points” in December if upcoming inflation statistics proved unfavorable. A basis point equals one-hundredth of a percentage point, making 25 the standard quarter-point increment used by the Fed.
Early Wednesday, Governor Christopher Waller informed CNBC that he supports a 50-basis-point increase in December, which is twice the typical quarter-point adjustment. Additionally on Wednesday, Governor Michael Barr stated that higher borrowing costs would likely remain appropriate, while San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly advocated for a measured strategy in raising them. Higher interest rates increase borrowing costs, which typically puts downward pressure on speculative assets like bitcoin.
These policymakers are responding primarily to CPI and PPI updates that revealed inflation spreading more broadly across everyday goods and services throughout October. However, that information is dated and fails to capture the recent decline in energy costs and wider commodity sectors. Energy has served as a primary driver of inflation since the conflict in Iran commenced at the beginning of March.
Crack spread, gasoline slide
The crack spread indicates a different reality. It represents the profit margin a refinery generates by converting crude oil into refined fuel, measured as the differential between its crude acquisition expenses and its revenue from selling gasoline and diesel.
The standard variation, known as the 3-2-1 formula, assumes three barrels of crude oil yield two barrels of gasoline and one barrel of diesel. When this spread contracts, it serves as an indicator that fuel prices are dropping faster than crude oil, prompting retail pump prices to follow suit.
The 3-2-1 spread has dropped 36% over a span of six weeks, moving from $65.56 down to $41.90 per barrel as of Wednesday, based on figures provided by James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at wealth management firm Wellington Altus.
Thorne noted that this descent demonstrates how pricing pressures have shifted downstream.
“Fat margins pulled refiners into running flat out, and now product markets are swamped. Gasoline and diesel prices are falling faster than crude. That’s exactly what wholesale RBOB futures, down 20%, and $3.78 at the pump were already signalling.”
RBOB futures represent the wholesale gasoline prices paid by refiners and commodity traders on the NYMEX. They declined by 11.1% followed by another 6.1% over the previous two full weeks, totaling a combined drop of roughly 16.5%. They dropped an additional 4.4% during the current week, bringing the three-week retreat close to 20%, marking the steepest decline since March 2020, according to CoinDesk’s evaluation of TradingView metrics.
Actual retail prices at the gas station are already decreasing. The AAA national average for regular unleaded stood at $3.75 per gallon on Thursday, representing a 12.8% decrease from a month prior and a 4.9% decline compared to a week ago. This figure still remains approximately 22% higher than levels recorded one year ago.
Thorne emphasized the significance of this trend regarding overall inflation.
“Collapsing margins also mean more relief is coming. Retail prices lag wholesale by weeks, so the pump hasn’t finished falling. Every 10 cents off gasoline takes about 9bp off headline CPI. November is shaping up for a negative headline print, and in March the war spike drops out of the year-over-year math,” Thorne said. “This is a supply glut, not a demand problem, and it’s doing the Fed’s job for it. Hiking 1% into a collapsing refining margin isn’t vigilance. It’s insanity.”
Commodity ETFs slide
This downward movement extends well beyond the gasoline market.
Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, monitored the performance of various commodity-focused funds as of Wednesday’s market close. This dataset focuses on exchange-traded funds, which track futures contracts and can diverge from immediate spot pricing.
For the month to date, the gasoline fund (UGA) has fallen 20.9%, the United States Oil Fund (USO) dropped 19.4%, and the Brent crude fund (BNO) declined 18.7%. Broad-market commodity funds are lower by approximately 12%, with copper (CPER) dropping 12.5%. Wheat (WEAT) has decreased 4.6%, corn (CORN) lost 2.7%, and gold (GLD) fell 4.1%. Natural gas (UNG) represents the primary exception, gaining 16.9% throughout the month.
Consequently, certain market participants perceive an alternative motivation behind the central bank’s posture.
“At this point, with multiple Fed officials calling for a 50-basis-point hike in December, despite clear easing of energy pressure on prices, I can only believe that the Fed is trying to crash the market verbally to give them cover to stop hiking altogether soon. Nothing else makes any sense,” James Lavish, co-managing partner of the Bitcoin Opportunity Fund, stated.
Meanwhile, interest-rate futures continue to price in quarter-point adjustments for December and January, alongside another potential move by April according to current market pricing.
Originally published at https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2026/11/19/fed-s-push-for-more-rate-hikes-leans-on-backward-looking-data-as-gas-prices-slide-analysts-argue.