A state judge in Manhattan is scheduled to review a request from New York on Monday for an injunction that Kalshi argues will shutter its trading platform “for every customer, everywhere,” despite the New York Attorney General’s assertion that this is not her intention.
On Friday, a federal judge in Manhattan dismissed the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s secondary emergency petition to block New York Attorney General Letitia James from advancing her lawsuit against Kalshi, marking a victory for the state that clears the path for a state court to evaluate an order on Monday morning that Kalshi warns will halt its exchange across the nation.
U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield issued the denial from the bench following a telephonic hearing that commenced at 5 p.m. ET on Friday. In an evening correspondence addressed to the state court, James’ department noted that Schofield determined the CFTC “was unable to show a likelihood of success on the merits that the CEA [Commodity Exchange Act] preempted state gaming laws.”
In legal battles against several states, the CFTC has maintained that the CEA implies prediction platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket fall under federal oversight, meaning local restrictions concerning sports wagering do not apply to them. U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff previously dismissed the agency’s initial emergency bid to halt enforcement within New York on July 31, the exact day James initiated her lawsuit.
Justice Melissa Crane of the New York County Supreme Court will review James’ petition for a temporary restraining order at 11:30 a.m. ET on Monday, according to gaming and sports counsel Daniel Wallach. The litigation returned to Crane on Thursday after U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick dismissed Kalshi’s motions to maintain the proceedings within federal jurisdiction.
‘Within or from New York’
The proposed injunction submitted by James would prohibit Kalshi from running an unlicenced wagering enterprise “within or from New York or to persons in New York,” encompassing contracts tied to sports, entertainment, elections, and “additional events.” Furthermore, the order would restrict Kalshi from permitting individuals under 21 to trade and would ban promotional campaigns on college campuses.
Sean Murphy, an attorney for Kalshi from Milbank, submitted a letter to Crane late Thursday night explaining that because Kalshi maintains its headquarters in New York, the injunction “would close down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere” and “would likely necessitate the liquidation of all open positions.” He additionally stated that the directive would contradict an August 11 CFTC emergency directive instructing Kalshi to continue operations.
James’ department responded on Friday asserting that it “does not seek to ‘shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere,'” and clarifying that the injunction would not prevent Kalshi from offering compliant futures or swaps. The correspondence encouraged Crane to assign zero weight to the CFTC directive, pointing to a November 10 decision by U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon which stated that the order “bears the hallmarks of a collaborative scheme between a regulator and a regulated entity to manufacture a claim of conflict preemption.”
“If Justice Crane incorporates the ‘from New York’ wording—effectively establishing a nationwide injunction—the following destination could be the U.S. Supreme Court’s emergency docket,” Wallach commented on X on Saturday. The broader conflict between state authorities and the CFTC may ultimately reach the Supreme Court, given that federal appellate courts have divided on whether individual states possess the authority to regulate Kalshi, with the Fourth, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits supporting the states and the Third Circuit favoring Kalshi.
The Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi during this week’s dispute involving Maryland regulators, although the two majority judges diverged in their reasoning. Judge Roger Gregory opined that federal statutes do not preempt Maryland’s wagering regulations even if Kalshi’s contracts qualify as swaps, whereas Judge Stephanie Thacker argued that the contracts fail to qualify as swaps entirely, stating: “What is occurring here is sports wagering.”
CFTC v. New York
The CFTC alongside the Department of Justice initiated legal action against New York in April regarding its attempts to limit prediction markets internally, contending that the federal agency holds exclusive jurisdiction over event contracts featured on federally registered exchanges, a stance maintained across numerous state-level disputes. The CFTC’s motion for a preliminary injunction in that specific matter has remained pending since May.
Within its Friday filing, the CFTC characterized James’ renewed petition as “yet another attempt to completely halt the operations of a CFTC DCM [designated contract market]” and stated that “New York aims to put Kalshi out of business entirely.” The regulatory body indicated that it requested New York that morning to delay enforcement actions until Schofield delivers her ruling on the injunction, and noted that the state explicitly declined.
In a separate development, Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour participated in the Democratic Attorneys General Association gathering held in Chicago on Thursday, Politico’s Daniel Lippman disclosed, referencing a witness account. Elisabeth Diana, a spokesperson for Kalshi, validated his presence to Politico but declined to disclose which specific attorneys general he conferred with. Politico did not specify whether AG James was in attendance.
The Block has reached out to Kalshi, the CFTC, and James’ department for statements.
Originally published at https://www.theblock.co/news/regulation/2026-11-21-kalshi-faces-monday-hearing-on-new-york-order-it-says-would-shut-down-its-exchange-nationwide-444813.