Representative French Hill and Senator Bernie Moreno stated that lawmakers squandered an opportunity to enact the Clarity Act while the momentum carrying the GENIUS Act remained high, yet they expressed differing views on the extent to which regulatory agencies can achieve results while market structure bills stay deadlocked.
During individual interviews on Thursday at the Capitol Crypto Forum hosted by The Hill and The Block, Hill contended that agency directives cannot offer the enduring legal stability that formal legislation supplies. Conversely, Moreno maintained that regulators could construct a large portion of the oversight framework themselves, even though he conceded that passing a law is the preferred method.
“I’m a little bit more bullish than French,” Moreno remarked. “I think it can accomplish 80% through a very rigorous rulemaking process that can’t be unwound.”
The legislator from Ohio further suggested that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Securities and Exchange Commission ought to utilize the upcoming two-year period to institute guidelines that would prove challenging for a succeeding administration to dismantle.
“Is that the right way to do it? No,” he supplemented. “I think the right way to do it is Congress should pass the Clarity Act.”
Hill, an Arkansas Republican who additionally leads the House Financial Services Committee, noted that following the collapse of the Clarity Act, regulatory bodies have largely mirrored the aims and trajectories outlined in market structure blueprints, though he emphasized that their jurisdictional reach has boundaries.
“My argument is it’s not a permanent fix. It is subject to litigation. It does not have the force of law,” Hill observed.
‘Time kills all deals’
Both Hill and Moreno agreed that splitting the GENIUS Act away from the Clarity measure was a strategic error, noting that the Clarity bill cleared the House but subsequently stalled following a failed Senate vote that occurred in September.
“I urged the Senate and the administration last summer to have Clarity and GENIUS passed together in the House,” Hill noted. “And I still stand by that.”
Moreno, who previously worked as an automobile dealer, utilized a commercial sales metaphor to describe the collapse.
“Time kills all deals,” he stated, explaining that legislators failed to capitalize on the enthusiasm generated by the stablecoin bill.
“The bill started at 300 pages, ended up at 600 pages,” Moreno explained.
Neither figure held strong expectations for enactment throughout the lame-duck legislative session. When questioned about what could realistically be accomplished across the following weeks, Moreno responded concisely: “Zero. Zero.”
Hill displayed a marginally more optimistic outlook, mentioning that politicians “never give up hope in a lame duck,” despite acknowledging that “the chances are not high.”
A possible reset
Hill pointed out that it was a positive indicator when Representative Maxine Waters highlighted digital asset market structure as a priority she plans to tackle if appointed as committee chair.
Moreno also asserted that bipartisan discussions remain a possibility, while attributing previous deadlocks to talks being “tornadoed” by arguments concerning President Donald Trump and ethical considerations.
He indicated he would be open to restarting negotiations utilizing the version of the bill passed by the House.
“By the time we got to September with the Senate version, it was just very, very, very complicated,” Moreno said.
Hill asserted that lawmakers still need to finish the job: “To have GENIUS but not market structure is a huge mistake.”
Originally published at https://www.theblock.co/news/regulation/2026-11-19-hill-moreno-blame-delays-missed-clarity-act-window-split-regulators-fill-gap-443615.