Brian Quintenz, a member of the Kalshi board and a former commissioner of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, remarked that insider trading occurs much more frequently in the equities market than across prediction markets, where spotting when an individual has altered the result of a traded contract is simpler.
“And there are by far more insider trading cases that happen in the stock market than anything that happens in the derivatives markets or in the prediction market space,” Quintenz stated on Thursday during the Capitol Crypto Forum hosted by The Hill and The Block. “It’s just easier to see because it’s very direct.”
Quintenz mentioned that the potential for insider trading should not render a market unlawful or invalid. He noted that punitive enforcement following a breach ought to complement the preventive measures taken by exchanges, while acknowledging that additional efforts remain necessary.
Who should be allowed to trade?
Dan Berkovitz, who serves as the vice chair of external and regulatory affairs at Millennium Management alongside his background as a former CFTC commissioner, pointed out that existing federal and exchange guidelines already outlaw insider trading. He explained that marketplaces also require specific guidelines regarding participant eligibility, encompassing staff members from associated entities and any individuals capable of swaying a contract’s outcome.
“So you need rules against insider trading, you need participation limits, and you need strict anti-manipulation provisions,” Berkovitz noted.
Berkovitz drew attention to mention markets, where results can hinge on whether a specific word or term is uttered. An individual who holds the power to utter a term likewise controls the contract’s resolution, he observed. Berkovitz expressed approval for the CFTC’s guidance but emphasized that further refinement is required regarding who holds inside knowledge or possesses the ability to influence outcomes.
“Who has influence or control of the contract? Who has insider knowledge? Those types of things, I think we can still use further development, but there’s initial steps being taken to get there,” Berkovitz said.
Christy Goldsmith Romero, an Atlantic Council senior fellow and another former CFTC commissioner, stated that exchanges act as the primary defense line against insider activity and suggested the CFTC will likely need to increase its involvement. She highlighted the mandate requiring exchanges to certify that their individual contracts remain resistant to manipulation. Furthermore, she stated that clearer direction from the CFTC is necessary to assist exchanges in fulfilling that obligation.
Quintenz concurred that supplementary guidance would prove beneficial. Nonetheless, he argued that determining whether a contract is susceptible to manipulation involves subjective judgment and that the CFTC ought to clarify how it enforces this benchmark instead of forcing exchanges to formulate disparate standards independently.
Regulation of sports contracts
The panel also touched upon the appropriate oversight for sports event contracts. Berkovitz clarified that the post-Dodd-Frank final regulations continue to ban gaming contracts through the CFTC, pending potential future regulatory revisions. However, the most recent interim regulation establishes a distinction between gambling executed inside a physical casino versus financial offerings listed on federally monitored exchanges, Berkovitz noted. He added that an unresolved legal question persists over whether identical financial products can qualify as a swap on one venue while being classified differently elsewhere.
Quintenz stated that he submitted an individual comment letter emphasizing that the 2018 Supreme Court sports betting decision did not grant states absolute exclusivity. He maintained that federal watchdogs can oversee trading venues while individual states maintain authority over casinos and sportsbooks.
Conversely, Goldsmith Romero suggested that the Supreme Court will likely address the issue due to conflicting rulings stemming from various Circuit Courts. “I think it’s likely that the prediction markets may end up losing on the sports contracts,” she remarked.
She also mentioned that the Securities and Exchange Commission might step up its involvement as prediction platforms expand their offerings to include publicly traded corporations and company shares. Finally, she stated that joint clarity efforts between both the SEC and the CFTC would be advantageous.
Originally published at https://www.theblock.co/news/markets/2026-11-19-kalshi-quintenz-insider-trading-prediction-markets-stocks-444133.